Federal Court Throws Out Gun Rights Ruling on Handgun Sales to People Under 21

A federal appeals court on Wednesday dismissed a July ruling that said a federal law banning handgun sales to young adults under the age of 21 was unconstitutional.

A panel of the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond unanimously ruled the case moot because the plaintiff in the case, a woman from Virginia named Natalia Marshall, turned 21 before the court’s decision became official, and is now able to purchase a handgun legally from licensed firearms dealers.

Although the 1968 Gun Control Act bars federally licensed dealers from selling handguns to people under age 21, they’re still allowed to sell long guns to those 18 and over. Exceptions to the age ban also exist for the limited purposes of employment, ranching, farming, target practice, or hunting.

In July, the same three-judge panel had ruled that a law passed by Congress in 1968 that sets a minimum age of 21 for purchasing handguns violates the Second Amendment right to bear arms.

The judges on Wednesday ruled that because Marshall is now 21, she no longer has a legally recognized interest in the outcome of the case. She filed the lawsuit against the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives (ATF) in 2018, when she was 18, after she was denied a handgun from a licensed firearms dealer because of her age.

When she filed the lawsuit three years ago, Marshall had said she wanted to purchase a handgun to be able to defend herself against her abusive ex-boyfriend, and other potential threats. Another plaintiff joined the suit but he has also turned 21.

“Despite efforts to add parties and reframe her claimed injuries, it is too late to revive this case. So it must be dismissed as moot,”Judge Julius N. Richardson, author of the court’s initial opinion, wrote on Wednesday.

“Once she turned 21, nothing prohibited her from buying the handgun she desired from a dealer of her choice. So her original claims are now moot,” the judge added.

Following the decision, Elliot Harding, Marshall’s attorney, said that he intends to challenge the court’s ruling.

“One way or another, these laws are going to continue to be challenged,” he said, The Washington Post reported. “It’s unfortunate that the government will evade the repercussions of the court’s thorough ruling simply because the nature of the laws at issue allow them to escape final review through our lengthy litigation process.”

The attorney added that the plaintiffs are disappointed “that the system continues to deny their equal access to fundamental liberties simply because of their youth.”

The Justice Department had asked the 4th Circuit to rehear the case after the first panel ruling in July found the law unconstitutional.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Isabel van Brugen

Isabel van Brugen



Isabel van Brugen is an award-winning journalist and currently a news reporter at The Epoch Times. She holds a master’s in newspaper journalism from City, University of London.

Source: Federal Court Throws Out Gun Rights Ruling on Handgun Sales to People Under 21

*This is a free press release. Upgraded press releases are ad-free!

Cyber Resilience in Smart Manufacturing

The possibilities of the transition to Industry 4.0 manufacturing processes are limitless. However, the rise of digital technology and greater connectivity marks a new level of complexity for manufacturers in the context of cyber security. What is cyber resilience? Simply put cyber resilience is ensuring your digital infrastructure is equipped to withstand sustained cyber-attacks. The…

Read Press Release

Mall Shooting Victim’s Family Hopes to Bring Body Home

BOISE, Idaho—A man who was killed in an Idaho shooting at a Boise mall on Monday was shopping for gifts for his family when he was wounded, family members said. Roberto Padilla Arguelles, 49, was a truck driver who lived part of the year in the southern Idaho city of Rupert and part of the…

Read Press Release

This Entrepreneur Is Defining Success on His Own Terms

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own. You’re reading Entrepreneur India, an international franchise of Entrepreneur Media. Any kind of successful social or business event follows proper event management planning. Event management skills are vital as they help in coordinating all the distinct elements of an event to make it both enjoyable and safe.…

Read Press Release

AEW Dynamite Results: Winners, News And Notes On October 27, 2021

CM Punk vs. Bobby Fish on AEW Dynamite Credit: AEW AEW Dynamite featured CM Punk vs. Bobby Fish, The Super Elite vs. Dark Order and first-round action from the AEW World Title Eliminator and TBS Championship tournaments. Last week’s broadcast of AEW Dynamite garnered 575,000 viewers for a Saturday night showcase. AEW Dynamite Ratings, Last…

Read Press Release

The best gel mattresses of 2021 – CNET

Many of today’s most innovative mattresses contain gel, whether as a layer on its own or infused into a type of memory foam called gel foam. Gel imparts key features like supportive pressure relief, reduced motion transfer, cooling properties, enhanced breathability and added buoyancy.When you shop, you’ll find gel in all-foam as well as hybrid mattresses, either fully…

Read Press Release

Men Who Take Six Months of Parental Leave Are ‘Losers,’ Says VC

(Bloomberg) — Joe Lonsdale, a founder of Palantir Technologies Inc. and a prolific venture capitalist, stoked a debate on Twitter about parental leave, saying any prominent man who takes six months off with his newborn is “a loser.”Most Read from BloombergA Deep Dive Into Squid Game’s World of InequalityMeet Six People Fighting Water Scarcity Across…

Read Press Release

Federal Court Throws Out Gun Rights Ruling on Handgun Sales to People Under 21 - Click To Share

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on reddit
Share on linkedin
Share on email
Share on whatsapp