UK has no coherent plan for Afghan refugee crisis, says ex-Whitehall chief

Britain and its allies have no coherent plan to deal with the huge refugee crisis expected to follow the Taliban’s takeover of Afghanistan, a former cabinet secretary has warned.

Mark Sedwill, a former ambassador to Afghanistan and senior adviser to two British prime ministers, said the emergency airlift out of Kabul had only helped “relatively small numbers” and greater pressures were likely to emerge as people fled overland.

Speaking at a Policy Exchange thinktank event, Sedwill said that while the US decision to exit Afghanistan after 20 years could not be changed, it had a series of important consequences that required action from Britain and the west.

“First, there will need to be a major humanitarian effort in and around Afghanistan. We will be very lucky indeed if there is not a really significant refugee crisis,” the former mandarin said, adding that the Taliban would have to run an “inclusive and wholly different government” from when they previously ruled, before the 2001 invasion.

He said of the departure of foreign forces from Afghanistan: “This is, in my view, a bad policy, badly implemented. It is an act of strategic self-harm.

“The Taliban’s victory in Afghanistan will undoubtedly fuel extremism and terrorism worldwide whether or not it is directed from there.”

Mark Sedwill
Mark Sedwill described the west’s withdrawal of its armed forces from Afghanistan as an ‘act of strategic self-harm’. Photograph: Roger Askew/The Oxford Union/Rex/Shutterstock

The achievement of the emergency airlift, in which 114,000 people were evacuated from Kabul in just over two weeks “can’t and shouldn’t conceal that overall, we do not yet have a coherent policy and plan in place to deal with refugee flows out of Afghanistan”, Sedwill added.

The UN refugee agency UNHCR has warned there could now be a further 500,000 Afghans crossing the border into neighbouring countries, on top of the 2.2 million who fled to countries such as Pakistan before the end of last year.

Thousands of people recognised as having a firm or likely claim for resettlement in the UK were left behind in Afghanistan when the airlift ended – leaving Britain to call directly on the Taliban to allow others safe passage out of the country. Many other western countries are in a similar position.

The foreign secretary, Dominic Raab, said on Thursday that evacuations might be able to resume from Kabul airport “in the near future”, as he began a tour of the region largely to solicit help in the evacuation of more people from the country.

On on a visit to paratroopers in Colchester on Thursday, Boris Johnson praised the British soldiers for their role in the UK airlift of more than 15,000 people from Afghanistan. The prime minister said: “When you look at the numbers that we’ve helped to come out … we’ve way exceeded the numbers we thought were eligible.”

But Johnson acknowledged he did not have a clearer idea of the number of people yet to be evacuated. He said: “The answer is there are some – and we care for them very much, we’re thinking about them, we’re doing everything we can to help.”

Last week the defence secretary, Ben Wallace, suggested that Afghans hoping to be evacuated to the UK might be better off heading to one of the country’s land borders, where Britain would accept claims made from neighbouring countries.

But there is also growing concern that Afghans who cross the border to a third country who thought they could come to the UK may not be able to – and in a subsequent briefing for MPs on Monday, Wallace said those considering fleeing should “use their judgment” as to whether to cross the border.

The resettlement entitlement for Afghan translators and others who worked directly for the British government is fixed – but the wider asylum rules for people who leave Afghanistan for a neighbouring country are yet to be determined.

Sarah Olney, a Lib Dem MP, said: “I no longer know whether I should be advising people to go across the Afghan border. What if people cross the border thinking they were entitled to come to the UK and were refused.”

Sedwill also warned that the goodwill of neighbouring countries could not necessarily be relied on, given the large numbers of Afghans who had already fled. “The neighbours really can’t absorb more,” he warned.

Speaking in Qatar on Thursday, Raab said he had “good conversations” with the Qatari emir, Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad al-Thani, about the “workability” of evacuations resuming from Kabul airport for UK nationals and Afghans who worked with Britain.

“I don’t think we’re yet able to say anything formal but that’s looking like it may happen at some point in the near future,” Raab told broadcasters.

Qatar, with the possible help of Turkey, is hoping to help reopen the airport shortly, starting with internal flights. “There is no clear indication when it is going to be fully operational yet but we are working very hard and also engaging with the Taliban,” the emir added.

Sedwill was the UK’s cabinet secretary and national security adviser from April 2018 to September 2020 and was Nato’s most senior official in Afghanistan a decade ago. But he was forced out of his last job by Johnson, with a promise that the UK would put him forward for the job of head of Nato in future.

There were already an estimated 2.2 million Afghan refugees in neighbouring countries, according to UN figures, before the latest crisis, which has caused tens of thousands to head to the borders as the Taliban seized control. The UNHCR estimates that in a worst-case scenario, as many as 500,000 more refugees could flee the country to Pakistan, Tajikistan, Iran, Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan in the coming months.

Source: UK has no coherent plan for Afghan refugee crisis, says ex-Whitehall chief

*This is a free press release. Upgraded press releases are ad-free!

The stainless steel air distribution industry

When it comes to manufacturing air distribution components for sterile environments, there’s no room for error. And because perfection is required for long-lasting, functional HVAC components, the right material and manufacturing processes are important factors.For everything from stainless steel grilles to air diffusers to HEPA filtration systems, the stainless steel air distribution industry is vitally…

Read Press Release

NTD Expands Its Service in Washington and San Francisco

NTD, The Epoch Times’ sister media, has expanded its service in Washington by partnering with local TV station WJAL. NTD has also added a new 24/7 channel on Comcast in San Francisco. The new launch makes NTD available to nearly 4 million additional cable subscribers. NTD currently broadcasts 24/7 on WJAL’s primary channel 68.1. WJAL…

Read Press Release

100k SOLR tokens will be airdropped ahead of the IDO

SolRazr has been observed getting overwhelming support from its communitySolRazr’s whitelist for the first IDO is now liveAhead of the IDO and whitelisting the protocol will do an airdrop of 100k SOLR tokensSolRazr is the DeFi tool on the Solana blockchain network. It is the first decentralized developer ecosystem for Solna. Notably, the protocol offers…

Read Press Release

FBI Investigates Alleged Attack on Female Soldier by Male Afghan Refugees at New Mexico Base

Marines with Special Purpose Marine Air-Ground Task Force-Crisis Response-Central Command guide evacuees on to a U.S. Air Force C-17 Globemaster III during an evacuation at Hamid Karzai International Airport in Kabul, Afghanistan, August 21, 2021. (Sergeant Samuel Ruiz/U.S. Marine Corps) The FBI has launched an investigation into the alleged assault of a female soldier perpetrated…

Read Press Release

UK has no coherent plan for Afghan refugee crisis, says ex-Whitehall chief - Click To Share

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on reddit
Share on linkedin
Share on email
Share on whatsapp