FAA Issues New Radar Altimeter 5G C-Band Risk Assessment Request to Aviation Industry

The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) on Thursday released its newest regulative policy declaration worrying prospective disturbance concerns dealing with airplane radar altimeter systems 2 weeks ahead of the prepared launch of brand-new 5G C-Band cordless networks. A Dec. 23 Special Airworthiness Information Bulletin (SAIB) released by the company asks “radio altimeter producers, airplane producers, and operators” to willingly take part in brand-new screening and evaluation of the altimeters included on their airplane “in combination with federal authorities.”

” The FAA is dealing with the air travel and cordless markets to discover a service that enables 5G C-band and air travel to securely exist together. While that work is underway, the FAA informed operators that Notices to Air Missions (NOTAMs) might be released to limit operations in locations where 5G disturbance is possible. It likewise offers extra details about airplane systems that might be impacted,” the firm stated in a declaration Thursday.

Separate demands were likewise released by the FAA in its SAIB for radio altimeter providers, airline companies and airplane producers to offer info about any disturbance problems they observe while flying or checking and evaluating the efficiency of their particular altimeter systems. A brand-new Safety Alert For Operators (SAFO) was likewise released by the FAA on Thursday in an effort to offer additional assistance on how brand-new NOTAMs will determine the geographical locations where particular operations needing a radio altimeter are restricted in the existence of 5G C-Band signals.

Ahead of the prepared Jan. 5 launching of 5G C-Band networks, air travel market leaders have actually mentioned that more time is required to develop a long-lasting resolution to the prospective disturbance concerns that this distinct brand-new kind of U.S.-based 5G connection provides to airplane radar altimeters. On Dec. 7, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) released brand-new airworthiness regulations (ADs) that will forbid particular kinds of innovative repaired and rotary wing landing treatments that count on using radar altimeter information.

A Dec. 20 letter gotten by Reuters includes remarks by Boeing Chief Executive Dave Calhoun and Airbus Americas CEO Jeffrey Knittel mentioning Airlines for America (A4A) analysis that if the most recent 5G regulation from the FAA had actually been active in 2019, about “345,000 guest flights and 5,400 freight flights would have dealt with hold-ups, diversions or cancellations.”

The main problem resulting in air travel leaders and regulators raising issue is driven by radio frequency spectrum management. On contemporary business and military airplane, radar altimeters are normally attached to the bottom of the airframe and transfer radio frequency signals to the ground or surface. The time that it considers the signal to reach the ground and show back up to the airplane is determined by the altimeter as its height above ground, upgraded regularly, several times per second.

Radio spectrum, according to the U.S. Department of Transportation, is divided into various frequency bands that have actually been assigned for information, voice, and cordless interactions utilized by a range of various markets. Airplane radar altimeters run within 4.2– 4.4 GHz, the lower half of which falls within the C-Band– a frequency variety from 3.7– 4.2 GHz where the mix of the variety of signal transmissions and capability are optimal.

The 5G cordless networks arranged to be turned on by AT&T and Verizon next month will take place within the 3.7– 3.98 GHz frequency variety, near to the altimeters. As the FAA suggested in its Dec. 7 ADVERTISEMENT, while it has actually heard issues from airline companies, the FAA, and airplane OEMs over the possible disturbance concerns positioned by the implementation of 5G in the C-Band, it has actually not yet existed with information or info that reveals altimeters are not prone to disturbance.

In a letter sent out to present FCC Commissioner Jessica Rosenworcel, 6 previous FCC commissioners dismissed the air travel market’s claims, mentioning that the problem was formerly solved.

” We are worried about the Federal Aviation Administration’s (FAA) current efforts to review the FCC’s 2020 choice to broaden versatile usage of the C-band for 5G, which followed practically 2 years of mindful evaluation of the general public record. The FAA must deal with the FCC and the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA), the federal company that handles federal spectrum usage and promotes federal stakeholders, to examine and fix the FAA’s issues expeditiously, however this argument ought to not be battled openly in a manner that weakens customer self-confidence at the same time, nor ought to it need months of extra hold-ups,” the letter states.

During a discussion provided on a Dec. 8 National Business Aviation Association (NBAA) webinar, Andrew Roy, director of engineering services for Aviation Spectrum Resources Inc. (ASRI) stated that as one of the groups leading the screening effort on the effect of 5G signal transmissions on radar altimeters, one issue has actually been an absence of clearness on the geographical areas of 5G C-band base stations and how the antennas on those stations will in fact work in regards to beam-forming possibly taking place within locations of airspace utilized by aircrafts and helicopters for crucial stages of flight.

Roy likewise appeared on NBAA’s Dec. 20 edition of its weekly Flight Plan podcast where he even more talked about the problem.

” Where is the antenna pointed from the 5G station– is it down at the ground? Is it up? These brand-new 5G antennas are really innovative and really smart,” Roy stated. “They can do what’s called beam steering and guide the energy in particular instructions digitally to make certain they get the very best protection possible. It’s an extremely creative system, however it’s extremely challenging for air travel then to state, well, where are you pointing the beam? This sort of level of information is what we’ve actually been attempting to acquire to make a precise choice.”

While the FAA’s brand-new regulations restrict making use of things like improved vision system shows to land in low exposure conditions at airports, it does provide radar altimeter makers the choice to prevent those constraints by requesting an alternate ways of compliance. This choice would need them to establish an alternate ways of compliance strategy that reveals their altimeters are not vulnerable to 5G disturbance.

Clay Barber, primary engineer with Garmin International, was likewise a visitor on the exact same podcast episode as Roy and mentioned that getting an alternate methods of compliance at this moment is not a choice due to absence of clearness, efficiency information, and details about how the 5G C-Band base stations will operate.

” I as Garmin, and Honeywell and Collins as radar altimeter producers, can refrain from doing that at this moment since we do not have the details that we might really make that case effectively with the FAA,” Barber stated.

Even as airline companies and other airspace users prepare to get used to the flight functional landing treatments and constraint requirements troubled their operations by the FAA’s regulations, some are still searching for a long-lasting resolution that supplies the very best result for both sides.

In emailed declarations to Avionics International, Anthony Rios, president of FreeFlight Systems– a Texas-based provider of radar altimeters and other avionics systems– stated that his business has actually been looking into the problem for numerous years and might have a service.

Right now, FreeFlight Systems remains in the lasts of the regulative accreditation procedure for a brand-new line of “Terrain Series” radar altimeters that are developed to deal with prospective disturbance from the 5G C-Band transmissions. He stated that most of in-service altimeters comply with Technical Standard Orders (TSOs)– a minimum efficiency requirement for defined products, parts, and devices utilized on civil airplane– were specified at a time when the frequency bands surrounding to the radar altimeter band were booked to low power applications and offered little danger to radar altimeter operations.

” The brand-new Terrain Series Radar Altimeters were particularly developed to deal with possible disturbance from high power 5G C-Band transmissions surrounding to our lower operating band. Acknowledging the result of high power transmission this near to the radar altimeter, we rapidly figured out that supplemental, external RF filters were just going to supply restricted defense in the frequencies beyond the radar altimeter bands. Rather, a brand-new, tidy sheet style would be essential to resolve in-band along with out-of-band disturbance. The resulting Terrain Series style surpasses passive RF filters which would just reduce the out-of-band disturbance and presents unique and sophisticated digital signal processing to accomplish high orders of signal rejection within the radar altimeter running band along with aggressive attenuation of disturbance outside the operating band,” Rios stated.

Rios, like numerous others in the air travel market, acknowledges the advantages 5G connection might give airline companies, airports, and aerial information sharing systems or services. Throughout 2021, significant U.S. airline companies made numerous statements about the adoption of brand-new 5G gadgets for staff members.

Earlier this month, for instance, Alaska Airlines signed a special 5G company arrangement with T-Mobile that will utilize the cordless network supplier’s 5G network– that runs in the lower 2.5 GHz band–” to enhance every element of the consumer experience from ticketing to check-in, on-time departures and arrivals, luggage tracking, and far more,” according to a Dec. 6 press release. In April, AT&T revealed a brand-new contract with Delta Air Lines to provide their flight attendants with 5G iPhones and followed up numerous months later on with a comparable offer to supply Delta’s pilots with 5G iPads.

JetBlue likewise highlighted the 5G abilities of the brand-new iPad Pro tablets that their pilots will be embracing in a July 13 press release.

Rios stated that FreeFlight’s method to reducing the possible 5G C-Band disturbance is to establish their newest altimeters based upon modeling of how prospective disturbance happens within in-flight situations.

” We have actually designed real-world test environments which consider the relative disturbance in between 5G C-band send power versus the deliberate shown signals that radar altimeters utilize to identify distance/height above ground. At 200 feet, the return signal from the Terrain series transmission will be more powerful than the return signal at 2,000 feet. 5G disturbance can be more frustrating at 2,000 feet than at 200 feet. Our test environment represents these signal levels at various heights and after that injects 5G disturbance to see where our altimeter ends up being unusable,” he stated.

Similar to the U.S. airline company market’s continuous adoption of 5G-enabled mobile phones, Rios thinks a long-lasting resolution will ultimately emerge.

” The Lower C-Band where radar altimeters run works well for broadband telecoms, and it has actually been clear for a long time that worldwide high powered broadband transmissions were going to be permitted better to the RADALT frequencies, therefore we began advancement of a brand-new altimeter that provided the optimum security we might craft into the style,” he stated. “There is a lot to learn more about C-Band 5G and its results to radar altimeters. As the 5G transmitters are released, the FAA will seek to market working groups to assist upgrade requirements appropriately.”

Receive the current avionics news right to your inbox