Everyone Does It This Way

Modern office building, near Great Portland Street, London, UK. (Photo by BuildPix/Construction … [+] Photography/Avalon/Getty Images)

Getty Images

It’s market standard to handle this particular issue this way. In the last 10 deals we’ve done, we’ve always resolved it this way. You’re off market to ask for something different.

That’s the argument one often hears in any interesting negotiation of commercial real estate documents. Instead of arguing based on what makes sense given the rest of the deal and the overall structure, one hears instead the argument that in all the other deals, the issue was resolved in this particular way.

Beneath the surface, the argument has a flavor that whoever is making it knows more than whoever is listening to it. The listener maybe doesn’t quite know what they’re doing. If they did know what they were doing, then they wouldn’t be so stupid and naïve to suggest handling this particular issue differently than the way everyone else handles it.

But what if the listener isn’t in fact that naïve or stupid? Often the listener has just as much experience with similar deals as the person making the argument. And in fact the listener’s experience is precisely the opposite. In the listener’s last 10 deals, the issue has always been resolved the way the listener wants to resolve it. That’s market standard, according to the listener.

So we’re even. The party making the argument thinks the other party doesn’t know what’s market standard. And whoever hears that argument typically has their own experience of what’s market standard, and has some doubts about whether the first party knows what they’re doing.

It’s a draw. One of the most common arguments in any commercial real estate negotiation ends up proving nothing at all.

Ultimately in these cases the parties will need to resolve their argument in one of two ways.

First, one party might have all the leverage, regardless of either party’s view of what’s market standard. In that case, the party that doesn’t have leverage will just have to go along or perhaps not do the deal.

More often, both parties have some leverage and some alternatives available. They’ll just have to figure out what makes sense given the logic of the larger transaction. Each party can pontificate all they want about how everyone else deals with the issue, but these parties will simply need to negotiate it out in a way that makes sense to them.

In one recent ground lease negotiation, counsel to the tenant’s lender – a household name – tried to use the “market standard” argument against the landlord. The ground lease under negotiation said that if the lender wanted to preserve its collateral, the ground lease, the lender would need to make any payments the borrower/tenant had failed to make under the ground lease. So far, so good, and quite ordinary.

But the lender’s counsel wanted to add a nuance: If the tenant owed money to the landlord because of some obligation of the tenant to indemnify the landlord for some risk (i.e., to pay any claims against the landlord because of that risk), then the lender wouldn’t have to make those indemnification payments. Those payments would simply be excused and the lender could still preserve the lease.

If the landlord accepted that position, then who would end up bearing the risk at issue? Answer: The landlord. If the landlord ended up writing a check because of the risk, the lender could step into the tenant’s shoes under the lease and preserve the lease without indemnifying the landlord for the risk at all.

The landlord didn’t like that idea, because it runs against the underlying structure of ground leases and leasehold financing. These leases are supposed to shift all risks away from the landlord. The tenant’s lender just has to accept that or not lend against ground leases.

The lender’s counsel said it’s market standard to handle the issue the way the lender wanted, so the landlord was being unreasonable.

The landlord stuck to its guns. Landlord’s counsel, who handles many ground leases, had never resolved the issue the way lender’s counsel wanted. According to the landlord’s counsel, the lender’s proposal was not only not market standard, it was also bizarre.

This time, the landlord prevailed. So maybe that’s “market standard” for the next transaction. Until it isn’t.

Source: Everyone Does It This Way

*This is a free press release. Upgraded press releases are ad-free!

The stainless steel air distribution industry

When it comes to manufacturing air distribution components for sterile environments, there’s no room for error. And because perfection is required for long-lasting, functional HVAC components, the right material and manufacturing processes are important factors.For everything from stainless steel grilles to air diffusers to HEPA filtration systems, the stainless steel air distribution industry is vitally…

Read Press Release

NTD Expands Its Service in Washington and San Francisco

NTD, The Epoch Times’ sister media, has expanded its service in Washington by partnering with local TV station WJAL. NTD has also added a new 24/7 channel on Comcast in San Francisco. The new launch makes NTD available to nearly 4 million additional cable subscribers. NTD currently broadcasts 24/7 on WJAL’s primary channel 68.1. WJAL…

Read Press Release

100k SOLR tokens will be airdropped ahead of the IDO

SolRazr has been observed getting overwhelming support from its communitySolRazr’s whitelist for the first IDO is now liveAhead of the IDO and whitelisting the protocol will do an airdrop of 100k SOLR tokensSolRazr is the DeFi tool on the Solana blockchain network. It is the first decentralized developer ecosystem for Solna. Notably, the protocol offers…

Read Press Release

FBI Investigates Alleged Attack on Female Soldier by Male Afghan Refugees at New Mexico Base

Marines with Special Purpose Marine Air-Ground Task Force-Crisis Response-Central Command guide evacuees on to a U.S. Air Force C-17 Globemaster III during an evacuation at Hamid Karzai International Airport in Kabul, Afghanistan, August 21, 2021. (Sergeant Samuel Ruiz/U.S. Marine Corps) The FBI has launched an investigation into the alleged assault of a female soldier perpetrated…

Read Press Release

Everyone Does It This Way - Click To Share

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on reddit
Share on linkedin
Share on email
Share on whatsapp